<p>While high school Rory might’ve made her fair share of interesting fashion (and, uh, life) choices, her chunky white sweater remains timeless, mostly because the autumn outfit pairings are endless. Take inspo from Rory’s simplistic styling and tuck yours into a pair of blue jeans, or pair the loose-fitted jumper with a plaid skirt and loafers—just to name a few options.<br></p><p>With this October marking the 23rd anniversary of <em>Gilmore Girls</em>, what better way to celebrate and emulate the series’ beloved protagonist than shopping for the look that started it all? While Rory’s exact sweater is no longer on the market, you can still channel your inner Rory Gilmore by snagging one of these 12 dupes, all under $300. Yeah, run, don’t walk! </p>”/>
Most Durable Dupe
L.L. Bean Double L® Cable Sweater
Most Durable Dupe
L.L. Bean Double L® Cable Sweater
L.L. Bean offers a forever staple that will remain in your closet for years to come. The Double L crewneck not only has a slightly fitted style but its ultra-soft cotton yarns are spun in a way that prevents pilling. Throw this bad boy on for a late-night walk in the park, wear it with leggings on those lazy WFH days, or layer it under your favorite coat in the winter. If the classic cream isn’t for you, you have 8 (!) other colors to play around with.
Rave Review: “I don’t think I’ve ever had a sweater this heavy and made so well! I agree with another reviewer; it screams quality like all other L.L. Bean items. Once I put it on, it felt so good and didn’t feel overly heavy. The knitting is great and soft.”
| Material | 100% cotton |
|---|---|
| Sizes | XS – XL |
| Fit | True to size |
| Colors | 9 |
Best Overall Dupe
H&M Regular Fit Wool-Blend Cable Knit Sweater
Best Overall Dupe
H&M Regular Fit Wool-Blend Cable Knit Sweater
H&M has a stock of chunky cable knit sweaters that look and feel like the real deal. Made from a wool-cotton blend, the Swedish retailer offers a Rory-like jumper adorned with the usual crew neck, sturdy long sleeves, plus ribbing at the neck, cuffs, and hem. While you could size up to embody the ultimate 2000s look à la Gilmore, H&M’s regular-fitted style is a great choice for layering underneath your outerwear of choice.
Rave Review: “Nice quality in fabric and design! It’s a little cropped, but I absolutely love it!”
| Material | 57% wool, 43% cotton |
|---|---|
| Sizes | XS – 3XL |
| Fit | True to size |
| Colors | 2 |
Best Bang For Your Buck Dupe
Aelfric Eden Oversized Knit Sweater
Best Bang For Your Buck Dupe
Aelfric Eden Oversized Knit Sweater
There’s a reason Aelfric Eden’s knit jumper is a customer favorite on Amazon. The material is so soft and thick, it’s even been compared to a blanket, which checks off the cozy box for an ideal fall and winter sweater. Priced at $53, it’s truly a lot of bang for your buck— and while it’s already tailored to give you that baggy-chic look, customers recommend going up a size to put the over in oversized.
Rave Review: “It’s one of the most comfy sweaters I own! It’s become my emotional support sweater, and I even wore it for four days straight…It’s really aesthetic, too, and much softer than it looks!”
| Material | 100% polyester |
|---|---|
| Sizes | XS – XXL |
| Fit | True to size |
| Colors | 5 |
Most Unique Dupe
Madewell Cable Knit V-Neck Crop Sweater
Most Unique Dupe
Madewell Cable Knit V-Neck Crop Sweater
Now 14% Off
There’s a reason why this Madewell sweater is a best-seller. It features the classic cable knit, but differs slightly from Rory’s oversized style with a V neckline and cropped fit. Not to mention, it’s made with a super soft cotton blend. This pullover paired with high-waisted bottoms? Chef’s kiss!
Rave Review: “Bought this in the store in the cream color, which stood out to me. The fabric is very soft and cozy. The fit is slightly oversized, but cropped to the top of my high rise jeans…Can’t wait to wear this.”
| Material | Cotton/acrylic/polyester |
|---|---|
| Sizes | XXS – XXL |
| Fit | True to size |
| Colors | 4 |
Gap’s cream-colored, all-cotton sweater looks and feels luxurious, with customers confirming it’s not scratchy compared to other options out there. The fit is slightly oversized, but it’s never a bad idea to go even bigger. Plus, at only $70 for such a high quality item, you might as well grab one before its all over TikTok.
Rave Review: “Soft, thick, and looks cute with my high-waisted jeans or to wear to work.”
| Material | 100% cotton |
|---|---|
| Sizes | XXS – XXL |
| Fit | Runs big |
| Colors | 4 |
Best High-Quality Dupe
Hill House Home The Kennedy Sweater
Best High-Quality Dupe
Hill House Home The Kennedy Sweater
Hill House Home knows a thing or two about making cozy sweaters, and their popular fisherman knit is no exception. It has everything you might look for in a cable knit sweater—chunky, naturally relaxed, and warm. Plus, it pairs well with any outfit during those chillier days.
Rave Review: “I looked quite a while for an ivory wool fisherman sweater that wouldn’t break the bank. I’m very pleased with the look of this one. Nicely made.”
| Material | 80% wool, 20% nylon |
|---|---|
| Sizes | XS – XXL |
| Fit | True to size |
| Colors | 2 |
Best Cropped Dupe
Cupshe Cable Knit Drop Shoulder Sweater
Best Cropped Dupe
Cupshe Cable Knit Drop Shoulder Sweater
A knit sweater of your dreams awaits at every corner, and this one is hanging out at Target. The Cupshe drop sweater is slightly different from the one Rory wears—it has a few inches knocked off the hem for those wanting a subtle cropped look. Still, it hits right at the waist, and is just as comfy. According to reviewers, the sweater also has a nice weight to it, meaning it’s not too thin or too bulky.
Rave Review: “I absolutely love this sweater! I am typically a size small, but I ordered a medium, and the fit is perfect…I think the cropped length is perfect without being too cropped and not too long! My new favorite sweater! Super comfy and soft!”
| Material | 100% acrylic |
|---|---|
| Sizes | XS – XL |
| Fit | Runs big |
| Colors | 1 |
Look no further than Sunday Best’s Peggy Sweater—a best-seller at Aritzia. There’s a reason it continues to be a customer favorite every season: It has the oversized fit, creamy color, and the classic cable knit stitching similar to that of the OG Gilmore Girls top. The Peggy Sweater looks so cute with one of the retailer’s pleated mini skirts and platform loafers, or with Rory-coded dark bootcut jeans and black ankle boots.
Rave Review: “Ordered in an XL for a super oversized fit, and it’s perfect. I am 5’9 and have a hard time finding knits that cover my butt for that oversized Scandi-girl vibe, and this does [the trick].”
| Material | 55% merino wool, 25% recycled nylon, 20% organic cotton |
|---|---|
| Sizes | XXS – XXL |
| Fit | Runs big |
| Colors | 17 |
Amazon Favorite Dupe
Amazon Essentials Fisherman Cable Long-Sleeve Crewneck
Amazon Favorite Dupe
Amazon Essentials Fisherman Cable Long-Sleeve Crewneck
Now 20% Off
This highly-rated Amazon Essentials fisherman sweater is too good to pass up. With sizes up to 6XL, the plush cotton pullover channels all of the traditional cable knit traits—from the oatmeal color to the classic texture. Its mid-weight quality means this sweater won’t be too breezy or too warm when you wear it on top of a tee or blouse. The sleeves come slightly elongated, says one reviewer, but you can use the extra length to cover your cold hands without stretching out the fabric.
Rave Review: “Nice quality in fabric and design!! It’s a little cropped, but I absolutely love it!!”
| Material | 100% cotton |
|---|---|
| Sizes | XS – 6XL |
| Fit | True to size |
| Colors | 21 |
Kotn’s cable knit sweater is everything you’re looking for—it’s relaxed with a high collar and slight bell sleeves. It’s also lightweight and warm, as it’s crafted from extra-fine lambswool that won’t leave you itchy. Customers rave about its exceptional quality and truly oversized fit.
Rave Review: “Honestly this is the nicest sweater I’ve ever bought! I can’t believe the quality–a thick, cozy, chunky knit and the marine blue is a gorgeous color. If you’re between sizes, I ordered a size smaller than usual and I’m very happy with the fit.”
| Material | 100% lambswool |
|---|---|
| Sizes | XS – XXL |
| Fit | Runs big |
| Colors | 2 |
Best Classic Dupe
Ralph Lauren Aran-Knit Wool-Blend Crewneck Sweater
Best Classic Dupe
Ralph Lauren Aran-Knit Wool-Blend Crewneck Sweater
Ralph Lauren is tapping into the dark academia aesthetic with its own rendition of the white fisherman sweater. This Aran-knit pullover features a crew neckline that fits just right. The silhouette is slightly baggy for those who want a more relaxed look. Additionally, its wool-nylon blend is ultra cozy, and offers a luxurious feel without the luxury price tag.
| Material | 45% wool, 35% nylon, 20% alpaca wool |
|---|---|
| Sizes | XXS – XXL |
| Fit | True to size |
| Colors | 1 |
Freelance Writer
Born and raised in Memphis, India Roby is a freelance journalist based in New York City. In 2021, India graduated from The New School with a Bachelor’s in Journalism and Design and a minor in Fashion Communication. Her bylines have also appeared in NYLON, Highsnobiety, Harper’s Bazaar, Arch Digest, Teen Vogue, Byrdie, and others. When she actually has free time, India enjoys brushing up on her Korean, making TikTok videos, and over-drafting her bank account. You can follow India on Twitter @india_roby and Instagram @indiajde.
Advertisement – Continue Reading Below
Advertisement – Continue Reading Below
